ai wrote:Well, I think having more than just that group of people in mind when creating the site will be useful

I'm not disagreeing, I'm defending my reasoning behind the way I laid out the site, perhaps some will gain a new perspective on the design with these notes.
ai wrote:A website should be appealing to as many groups as possible.
I'd have to disagree with this, it should hit the top of the bell curve of your target audience. In Nexuiz' case, I believe it's mostly bored people looking for a free game or classic quake players looking for a good alternative to relive their glory days.
ai wrote:And yeah, I agree with the shiny look, it doesn't fit here and too much of it looks bad. However, I hear that the new 2.4 menu is somewhat shinish so maybe that design would fit better. But still yet, more industrial look to it (should be doable even with shiy stuff), right now it all reminds me of Apple and their style.
Personal preference. I designed it with the new menu system in mind but tried to give it a bit of a 'pop'
ai wrote:Buttons needs to be remade, in my opinion they look too much like ad buttons, those that sane people never click on. A donate buttons should be suddle but still visible in the corner of the eye, don't wanna seem to desperate

People hate that.
Black on black isn't subtle? Developers is light blue...
Please take time into consideration as well. This website should be appealing to a first time visiting, pitching them whatever product it is you're trying to push, in this case, the game Nexuiz. When they first get there, they will see the movie and figure out what this website is for... they ignore the links on the side mostly, thats fine. Those links on the side are for frequent visitors that are looking to help out, unless of course they came to the site for that particular reason, in which case the 'ads' are relatively easy to locate.
ai wrote:However, I do like the bit nexuiz chikara logo. Like a trademark.
Cool, I like it too
ai wrote:EDIT: Oh and, what false 'strenght' icons on ouns? Those are genuine (yet not official, but genuine).
Oblivion wrote:Did you know the current logo for Nexuiz is actually the japanese Katakana character for 'Ka'?
I'm open to suggestions, but please don't tell me negative things about my work without having a positive solution. I'd appreciate it if you'd cite your sources, pictures of styles you like... links to websites you like... etc.